Task
10.1.2.5. Make a good-faith attempt at the requirement first
Recommended Often forgotten
In some cases it is obvious that a Scout cannot do a requirement, but often it is not obvious until they have tried. The Guide states its reason plainly: Scouts regularly surprise their leaders and parents by doing more than the adults expected.
Notes and warnings
Tip. A good-faith attempt is worth making even when the outcome looks certain, because the description of what happened is exactly what the council advancement committee needs in order to decide. "We know it is impossible" is harder to act on than "here is what happened when we tried".
Where this step comes from
- Guide to Advancement (2025), Section 10.1.2.5 · Why a good-faith attempt is preferred before an alternative is approved.